What’s the difference between “race” and “species” and when should you use what in your fantasy settings? I’ve taken a look into this myself and made the right choice for me. Read on for ideas on making the right choice for you.
Race
What’s a race? The answer can be complicated (but interesting reading), but race has been described as nothing more than a social construct to describe different versions of homo sapiens (i.e., humans), who are 99.9% the same, having no genetic differences to warrant classification (into “races”).
Since elves, dwarves, and other races in fantasy are invented, no genetic material exists to determine if they are, in fact, genetically different from humans. One could assume that the pointed ears of elves must mean something, but on Earth, some races have stereotypical eyes, noses, etc, and are still the same species. So this suggests such minor differences are not genetic and races in fantasy are just that: still homo sapiens that people have divided into “races” as an artificial construct to classify people.
Of course, “small people”, aka, dwarves, do exist on Earth, but their distinctive height and other characteristics are caused by a medical or genetic disorder, which is only sometimes passed down from parents, meaning it is not a definite outcome, as one would expect if they were indeed a different species or even a race of one. They are still humans. You wouldn’t expect a dwarf in a fantasy setting to give birth to a human, right?
Species
If races don’t really exist on a biological level, “species” is the other obvious term to use, but that has problems, too. Even biologists struggle with the definition of species, known as the “species problem”. If they can’t define it, far be it for us to do so. The word is just used to group similar organisms and is what the average person thinks of when considering a cat vs. a dog, for example.
How are we mere creative writers to make a decision?
Species can interbred and produce offspring (in fact, that’s a part of the problematic definition), so this shouldn’t figure in your thinking between “race” and “species” because both can do it, rendering this moot.
The Status Quo
I’m generalizing, but most fantasy books use “race”, probably because J. R. R. Tolkien’s influential Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit popularized these, along with the later Dungeons and Dragons fantasy role-playing games. It became expected and lots of people followed along, either not caring about a distinction or finding it too problematic and of no consequence to most people, all valid reasons, really.
One explanation for “races” that’s given in some fantasy books is that beings like elves were created from humans, or vice versa, and therefore elves and humans are races of the same humanoid species. If this is the case in your world, then “race” makes sense.
Degree of Difference in Your Fantasy Races
One way to make a decision is to consider how different your creations are from each other and humans. Elves, dwarves, hobbits, orcs, humans, and other fantasy tropes and conventions are pretty similar, making “race” a fine choice (they are the same species).
On the other hand, if one creation has wings, another has gills and other adaptations for the water, and another has four legs, these are more suggestive of being different species. Dragons are clearly another species from homo sapiens, for example.
Also consider that on Earth, we call Caucasians, Asians, and other versions of humans “races”, so if these exist in your world, you pretty much have to do that, too. If you also have elves and dwarves, or similar humanoids, are you going to call those races, too, when you and your readers think of them as more different than Asian/Caucasian races of humans? This is an inconsistent and confusing use of the word “race”.
My Decision
I’ve been creating one setting for most of my fantasy books for over 25 years, on and off, and invented seven species, which I used to call races. I changed my mind for several reasons, in no particular order:
Reason 1
I can’t call Caucasian, Asian, and other versions of humans “race” and also call my other humanoids, who are not human, race, because that doesn’t make sense. (Asian is an Earth term, but you get the idea).
Reason 2
To be different and pull readers out of their comfort zone of expectations.
Reason 3
Some of my creations have multiple versions that are quite different from each other. It makes sense to call each a species with multiple races of that species.
For example, let’s say I have three humanoids called dokai, lokai, both with wings and similar bodies, and a third with horns and a tail, called soman. And I decide to call all three races. This doesn’t really work because dokai and lokai are basically the same (one is good, maybe the other corrupted to be evil) and soman are different. How can I say dokai and lokai are two races and so are soman? If I do, then what word do I use to describe the difference between dokai and lokai? I can’t use race because I’m already using that at a higher level.
It makes more sense to say dokai and lokai are races of a parent species, kai (a syllable found in both names, giving readers a clue), and soman is a separate species. For example:
Not good
- Races
- Dokai
- Lokai
- Soman
- Humans
Better
- Species
- Kai
i. Dokai (race of kai)
ii. Lokai (race of kai) - Soman
- Humans
i. Asian (race of humans)
ii. Caucasian (race of humans)
iii. Etc.
- Kai
Coda
In the end, only you can make this choice and there’s really no right or wrong one. Some who feel strongly one way or another will tell you otherwise, but it’s your world and you are its ultimate god.
Creating a Fantasy City, Part 1
Without cities, towns, and villages, no fantasy world building project is complete. In part 1, we’ll look at some things to consider. Part 2 will be the template I use for creating a new settlement. Location, Location, Location No settlement Read More …
Creating a Fantasy City, Part 2
Below is the template I use when creating a fantasy city during world building. Feel free to adapt it your purposes. You can read Part 1 here. Download the PDF or Word template. City/Town Name General Alliances Independent city or Read More …
Creating Fantasy Names For Your Fiction Stories
Depending on your ability, creating names for people, places, and beings in fantasy books can either be fun or a pain. I’ve been doing this for three decades and will provide some tricks and thoughts to help. KISS KISS doesn’t Read More …
Fantasy Species vs. Race?
What’s the difference between “race” and “species” and when should you use what in your fantasy settings? I’ve taken a look into this myself and made the right choice for me. Read on for ideas on making the right choice Read More …
How Mountains Affect Rainfall
When drawing maps of continents, being realistic is a good idea even when inventing for a fantasy or SF landscape. We’re not freed from plausibility unless we’re purposely throwing out the laws of physics and nature. Most of us are Read More …
How to Create Fantasy Races or Species, Part 1
In this three part series, we’ll look at creating races in fantasy books. This entry focuses on the physical considerations, while Part 2 will discuss the mental ones. Part 3 includes a downloadable template you can use. While using the Read More …
How to Create Fantasy Races or Species, Part 2
In part 1, we looked at some physical considerations when creating races in fantasy books, while building your own world. Now we’ll look at some mental aspects. Mental Considerations Worldview When I watch alien species/races on TV or see them Read More …
How to Create Fantasy Races or Species, Part 3
In Part 1 we discussed the physical aspects of creating races in fantasy books. Part 2 covers the mental. Now we’ll look at a downloadable template you can use as a starting point to aid your creative writing. Download the Read More …
How to Create Plants and Animals for Your Fantasy Setting
In another blog, I discussed whether you should create plants and animals for your fantasy setting. Assuming you’ve decided to do it, here are tips for doing so. New Ideas If you already have ideas, you can just write them Read More …
How to Draw a Fantasy Map, Part 1
One of the fun aspects of fantasy world building is drawing maps. This blog provides some ideas to keep in mind and tools to help. Some of this is kind of obvious but worth mentioning anyway. Where to Start A Read More …
How to Draw a Fantasy Map, Part 2
In Part 1, we looked at where to start and basic continent considerations for drawing a fantasy map. Now we’ll look at some geographical considerations. Remember Geography Having a basic sense of geography is important or your map won’t make Read More …
My Guest Post
Today, author John Robin was kind enough to publish a guest post of mine about species and races in world building. You can read it here. The article is drawn from Creating Life (The Art of World Building, #1), which Read More …
Should You Create Plants and Animals in Your Fantasy Setting?
When world building, I used to think there was no point in inventing animals and plants for a fantasy setting. After all, they’re often just variations on real Earth animals, in which case, why bother? For example, maybe you have Read More …
I have just had the same issues with Dragons. In the end, part of my decision making is that although I have lots of different types of dragons, they can breed with each other, therefore they kind of have to be the same species. In my description of dragons in the website I am doing to accompany my new books, I have pointed out that the dragons themselves use the term “peoples” though occasionally they do say species, which is inaccurate.
Well, intelligent species are allowed to use the wrong word sometimes!
Haven’t finished the article yet, but you can read it thus far: http://aworldcalleddirt.com/abbey/history/natural-history/dragons/
CC
Oh, I should make another point. Many people (including me) create dragons that have 4 legs and wings. That makes them Hexapods, not quadrupeds like everything else is.
Evolutionarily speaking, that is a problem! On Dirt I have made sure I have a couple of other six legged species, just to add a little balance.
Thanks for the comments. Why is it a problem to have 6 legged animals, too? Curious if you’ve researched something I haven’t
So glad I stumbled on your post because I’ve been having this same discussion, i.e., whether to use the term race or species in fantasy worlds, with a friend. It’s great to hear another’s reasons and thought process. Cheers!